Had Your Global Entry Taken Away? Court Says DHS Decisions Now Subject To Review [Roundup]

News and notes from around the interweb:

About Gary Leff

Gary Leff is one of the foremost experts in the field of miles, points, and frequent business travel - a topic he has covered since 2002. Co-founder of frequent flyer community InsideFlyer.com, emcee of the Freddie Awards, and named one of the "World's Top Travel Experts" by Conde' Nast Traveler (2010-Present) Gary has been a guest on most major news media, profiled in several top print publications, and published broadly on the topic of consumer loyalty. More About Gary »

More articles by Gary Leff »

Comments

  1. The US Government’s administrative actions should be subject to court review when those administrative and arbitrarily-determined actions target individual Americans. Americans should also have a right to know what the USG has recorded about and used against a petitioning American.

  2. Good on the DHS one. Regulatory bodies should not be immune from judicial oversight. Let them act (don’t make it so a big company can tie things up in court for years), but let a court review the actions.

  3. @GU and @Loren … + for your good intentions , but what if the Judge reviewing the matter doesn’t have a clue ? I’d rather take my chances appealing to the agency , than spend a lot on lawyers trying to get a judicial review .

  4. It’s still going to be possible to appeal to DHS. The Appeals Court is saying that Americans have a legal right to seek redress and review in court when DHS administrative action alienates a US person over a GE application or GE membership status. And if a federal court gets it wrong enoug, there are appellate courts that are available.

  5. Red flag laws do work in parts of the EU to get guns out of the hands of domestic violence perpetrators. That saves lives. Do GE and other “trusted traveler programs” save lives? If they do, then GE and TTPs should be scrapped by US DHS and all free US persons should be treated as if all are GE/TTP members.

  6. Sooner or later a traveler tracking down their stolen forced checked bag will get seriously injured or killed by an airport worker who is also a thief. In that case the airline should be liable to a high jury award. In this case, the passenger should have been carrying a thin nylon bag so she could have removed her valuables to take into the cabin before turning her pink hard-shell carry on suitcase in for checking. At least that is what I have in my carry on for that reason.

  7. @jns … +1 . It can be an imminent danger to oneself , when having a dispute with a thug .

    Once , at the Nile Hilton , I was snarky and told the waiter I did not want “Egyptian coffee” , when he tried to talk me into ordering it . He exploded into a rage and the manager finally took him away .

    Once I snarkily asked a Georgia shuttle bus driver to turn down , or turn off , a loud music station . She stopped the bus and said if I speak again she will throw me off .

  8. Those judges are so corrupt. The whole decision against the government is rigged, rigged, rigged. Why does the government, and former Presidents, be subject to these laws???? It’s a crime, it’s criminal what they did — DHS should be able to do what it wants. Sad, real sad I tell you.

  9. I haven’t renewed my global entry. No need for it: Mobile passport still gets me to bag claim before my bag makes it.

  10. Too often MPC is either off or not operating at all at the airports for my flight arrivals, and so I have great use for GE those times. And since I have excess TTP credits to use from credit/charge cards, a renewal application was both quick and easy with even a quick turnaround direct to final approval status.

  11. @GUWonder: I haven’t had any issues yet with MPC, but my international travel is down and sample size small and I almost always arrive at ORD – so maybe I’m just getting lucky with some part of that combination.

  12. CLT had MPC off this past weekend.

    MPC was useless at JKF T4 early last week in the late morning. Also in May, MPC was useless to save time at MSP for my flight. [Again, a couple of elderly Somalis with US visas got through to baggage claim at MSP faster than me as a GE member and potential MPC user.]

    Last month, MPC at ORD was again working to save time. Earlier in the spring, MPC was also a time saver for my flights into LAX and SFO.

    For what it’s worth, my last GE renewal application went from application submission to final approval within around 24-36 hours. I actually was sort of disappointed that it got approved so fast.

Comments are closed.