Accused Of Stealing A Plant At Ritz-Carlton — Guest Billed And Shamed Without Proof

A guest at the Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner (generally considered one of, if not the worst Ritz) was accused of stealing a bamboo plant from their room, and billed for it. The hotel treated them like a thief when they objected, eventually taking the charge off their bill as a “courtesy” clearly believing he was, and treating him like, an undesirable.

I stayed at a ritz over the weekend and when my bill came, there was a fee added with a note that said “bamboo removed”. I had no idea what this meant, so I called the hotel to ask about the charge. Apparently, housekeeping had reported that a bamboo plant was taken out of the bathroom and it was charged to my bill.

I of course did not take said plant, and told the person on the phone it must have been a mistake and asked him to please remove the charge. He refused to remove it and said they needed to “investigate” by talking to the housekeeping staff.

I continued to reiterate that I did not take any plants and he kept telling me “we will only remove the charge if we can confirm from housekeeping it was a mistake”. He called me back later in the day and said they would take off the charge as a “courtesy” but basically insinuated that they can’t confirm I didn’t take this plant.


Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner

It’s frustrating to me that a hotel simply decides you owe them money, bills you, and there’s no real adjudication possible (outside of going to court). You could dispute a charge with your credit card issuer, and risk getting banned by the chain.

And even more telling about the Ritz brand that the customer would be treated this way unless they were 100% certain that the guest was a thief – rather than treating the standard of review as the customer would be treated as one unless proven otherwise.


Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner

People Steal From Hotels All The Time

Of course, people do steal from hotels. That’s why many hotels have been embedding RFID chips in towels for over a dozen years. A single hotel has saved $16,000 per month by reducing its towel thefts each month from 4,000 down to 750 by attaching washable RFID tags to its towels.

The Nairobi Hilton once prosecuted someone for stealing two towels and they received a two year sentence. Twenty years ago IHG promoted ‘towel amnesty day’ but honestly I wouldn’t expect towel theft to be so common in a world of checked bag fees, who travels with extra space for towels?

Five-star hotels are more likely to see higher-value items taken – like tablet computers, artwork, TVs, and mattresses. Forty nine hotels reported mattresses being stolen in a two year period. In 2018 a family was caught on video in Bali with items stolen from the hotel they stayed at packed in their luggage. The hotel demanded they open their bags for inspection and a big argument ensued. As the bags are searched one stolen item after another gets revealed.

We’ve heard about a grand piano stolen from a Sheraton lobby, and about guests who steal televisions from their room. And, would you believe: carpet, light fixtures, curtains and mirrors? Even door hinges have been stolen. The Four Seasons Beverly Wilshire (the Pretty Woman hotel) had a fireplace stolen.

By the way, people also steal pretty much everything out of airport lounges.

I’ve Been Accused Of Stealing From A Hotel

I was once accused of stealing coffee by the Sheraton Macao. I ordered a pot of coffee from room service. They explained that I could tell them how many cups of coffee I wanted, and that’s what they would fill the pot to. So I asked for 6 cups that my wife and I would share.


Sheraton Macau

A short while later room service delivered the coffee. It seemed awfully light for 6 cups. I poured two cups, and the pot felt nearly empty. So I called back down to in room dining. The same person I ordered from answered, and she remembered that I had ordered 6 cups. She said she’d send up 4 more cups right away.

So at 6:30 a.m. there’s a knock on the door, and the man who delivered the first pot of coffee appeared. He didn’t have a pot of coffee in his hand. Instead he declared: “I am here to investigate.”

I told him that we had ordered six cups of coffee, I poured two and that’s all there was. He lifted the pot of coffee and said, “there’s still some left”.

He then said it’s not possible that we could have gotten less coffee, because the machine is electronic. They specify how much goes in the pot. There I am, standing in a bathrobe in my hotel room, being told that it’s not possible that I could be missing coffee and in any case the coffee I ordered was right there, in the pot!


Sheraton Macau

What was I trying to pull, anyway? He thought I was trying to cheat the hotel, to get extra coffee without paying for it.

He then poured the remaining coffee from the pot into an empty cup. It filled only half way. I said, “You were right, there were actually two and a half cups.”

He harumphed, walked directly outside the room, and handed me the pot he had brought along with the four replacement cups of coffee I had been promised — once I satisfied him that I wasn’t actually trying to steal coffee.

About Gary Leff

Gary Leff is one of the foremost experts in the field of miles, points, and frequent business travel - a topic he has covered since 2002. Co-founder of frequent flyer community InsideFlyer.com, emcee of the Freddie Awards, and named one of the "World's Top Travel Experts" by Conde' Nast Traveler (2010-Present) Gary has been a guest on most major news media, profiled in several top print publications, and published broadly on the topic of consumer loyalty. More About Gary »

More articles by Gary Leff »

Comments

  1. We stay at this hotel often. Those plants aren’t more than 8-10″ tall. Who knows when the absence was noticed? Sad they gave this guest such a hard time.

  2. Catch 22. People ruined it for others. Trying to catch the thieves to legal standing is impossible. The ones squarely caught just pay the price of item stolen and move on. No incentive to stop attempting. Like shoplifting enforcement. People continue stealing, guests continue paying.

  3. Bizarre! I had no idea!! Clearly I move in very naive and/or innocent circles, but this just boggles the mind.

  4. Ten years ago I used a washcloth to clean up after I spilled some red wine in the room at the Hilton Xi’an. I got charged $5 USD. However, I did take their cloth laundry service bag, so I guess we’re even. I still use it as my travel laundry bag.

  5. I’m naive also. This boggles my mind. People steal TV’s and…..carpet? Geez

  6. Jeez, the plant probably died or was out for re-potting. ( I think they use a contractor for the plants and their maintenance ). I would have been quite angry at the accusation.

  7. Not being able to defend yourself and then getting your money back for something you didn’t do as “a courtesy” is so frustrating. They should put an RFID chip or something on items they don’t want stolen. Otherwise if you can’t prove it don’t put it in your rooms to begin with.

  8. 45 years ago at a hotel in Canton, China (“The Tuing Fong) I broke a glass, and the hall boy cleaned the broken glass and gave me a bill for 5 cents which was added to my bill — Around the same time, I stayed at a hotel Shanghai , at check out I was online to pay my bill and was told I was going to have to pay for that night because I checked out 10 minutes late ( because of the long line ) refused to pay

  9. A tempest in a coffee pot. The LEGAL standard for whether or not the charge is valid is whether the charge is supported by a “preponderance of the evidence” — 50.1% likelihood. The hotel has the burden of proof. The burden of proof is generally not met when it is merely he-said/she-said, which this was. The hotel was legally entitled to investigate the charge before agreeing to anything, so that criticism is wrong.

    The hotel correctly removed the charge promptly, so the rub here is the hotel claimed it was a courtesy, when it was really a burden of proof issue. When a correct legal result is achieved, but the stated reason for the result is erroneous, it will not be disturbed on appeal.

  10. I can’t believe they gave you an issue over coffee! I mean, I got enough coffee for probably 100 pots for like $8, that’s like 8 cents a pot.

    I bet they DID tell their machine to pour 6 cups — it seems like the line on mine that is for “12” is probably a good 3-5 cups or so. I suppose the coffee ‘cup’ is the actual liquid measurement (per Google, 1 cup is 8 fluid ounces), while (unless you were drinking a strong espresso) I doubt anyone really drinks an 8 fluid ounce coffee, and I doubt the hotel coffee cups were that small either.

  11. Maybe I missed it but I cannot find anywhere in the linked reddit thread what was the actual amount in question.

    Not that it is consequential as the guest obviously shouldn’t have been charged.

    As to the coffee story, my office coffee maker has a very, uh, stingy definition of what one cup is. So like @hwertz I would also bet they did in fact set the machine to 6 cups.

  12. I think more often than not, you don’t get charged for damaged items. I have long stopped taking any towels (it was tempting as a teenager, but I think that was before RFIDs were invented) but I can’t imagine taking a plant. It would just DIE in transit!

    I did leave a lamp destroyed at the St. Regis in Aspen once, and no one made a fuss. I was guilty and expected something to come out of it, but it never did.

    Although a TV or mattress would present an interesting challenge… 🙂

    A fireplace though? I’d like to meet THAT hotel guest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *