A group of about 50 French Jewish children, aged 10-15, were kicked off of a Vueling flight in Valencia along with their camp director. They were enroute back to France.
The group was singing Hebrew songs onboard the Airbus A320, triggering objections from crew. Vueling staff reportedly called Israel a “terrorist state” and didn’t want Hebrew singing onboard. The camp director, a 21‑year‑old woman, was forcibly removed from the aircraft and “arrested and beaten.”
After he stopped singing, police stormed the plane a few minutes later, ordering the band director and the children to leave the plane, which had not yet taken off… Once they left the plane, the police ordered them to place their cell phones on the ground to check that the arrest had not been filmed, prompting the director to intervene, claiming that what they were doing was illegal.
The police officers then pinned the 21-year-old woman to the ground and handcuffed her before taking her away, while the children aged between 13 and 15 remained with their instructors.
Israel’s Diaspora Affairs Minister Amichai Chikli shared video of the incident:
The woman who was arrested and beaten is the director of the Kinneret summer camp.
Fifty Jewish French children, aged 10 – 15, were singing Hebrew songs on the plane.
The @vueling airline crew said that Israel is a terrorist state and forced the children off the aircraft; they… https://t.co/V78PEHB58B pic.twitter.com/HizF6SZoaD
— עמיחי שיקלי – Amichai Chikli (@AmichaiChikli) July 23, 2025
Vueling, which is owned by British Airways parent IAG, has not released any official public statement or social post from the airline has been issued. Spanish authorities have made no formal comment beyond acknowledging that police were involved in enforcing airline crew requests.
I can understand objecting to a group singing, playing musical instruments, or nearly anything else on a plane. I can understand politely asking them to stop. Having an issue with the singing because or responding to it by saying that “Israel is a terrorist state” is certainly one way to handle things. Vueling, it seems, decided to globalize the intifada. Meanwhile, Spain expelled Jews in 1492 – but ironically this time wouldn’t let them leave.
Update: Here’s additional video of the group being bused after being kicked off the aircraft.
“We’re not going to give these antisemites the opportunity to kick us off the plane”
A counselor for the Kinneret Club teens who were kicked off a Vuelling flight for singing a Hebrew song explains why they now need to hide their kipot and tzitzit on the plane to avoid any… pic.twitter.com/TQyoylSNYp
— Hen Mazzig (@HenMazzig) July 24, 2025
Could we call this KARMA?!
The level of antisemitism in the world is absolutely vile! I hope the airline gets sued out of existence.
Expect more of the same going forward.
RunningJock, can we call you a racist and anti-Semitic?
RunningJock: If you’re willing to accept what Karma would be for a murderous rampage across Israel.
Since you’re blaming Israel for defending itself, it’s clear that you didn’t leave the lesson, and you have successfully been duped by the world MSM and governments who shamelessly partner with Hamas in amplifying their outlandish propaganda.
The Karma will be when there are no more Brits and Spaniards left. You let them take over your countries, and you’re surprised?
@ RunningJock – if you’re a f**king anti-Semite, which obviously you are.
There’s no circumstance under which this is remotely acceptable. But, they’re FRENCH, they’re not Israeli. I’m too enraged to properly respond.
Long time poster here, and an actual camp director and I sell scheduling software for camps. (I was able to get camp scheduling dot com).
Something is really off here. I have escorted many buses and flights and while there has been interesting incidents, there is always a reason why things get out of hand? Or exaggerated.
Clicks sell. Let’s get the data first before making judgements.
@running jock
GFY
We will never be beat
Nobody gives a sh1t about the gazans
People have tried for years to destroy us but a~hols like you we chew for breakfast
I respect that flight crews can basically remove anyone they want off a plane for almost any reason, however, this just doesn’t feel right at all. They’re children! When a Christian Bible camp brings out the guitars and starts singing on a Southwest flight (see: April 2022, “How Great Is Our God”), why is no one kicked off there? This is also especially odd, because there’s a large Sephardic diaspora in Spain and Portugal; you’d think they’d be more aware. *sigh* Welp, even before this, I knew better than to trust Vueling unless I really have to (there are, after all, more nonstops to BCN with them to unique airports).
Ultimately it’s the MSM, the UN and all its organs, the human “wrongs” NGOs, and certain Western governments who are responsible for constantly fueling the flame of Jew hate worldwide with their daily propaganda.
In a normal world, none of these stories would be published as they are such obvious lies. Check out Gazawood for thousands of Pallywood videos.
Low cost = Low class crew..
With an uneducated, brainwashed, racist crew, what do you expect?
“police stormed the plane a few minutes later, ordering the band director and the children to leave the plane, which had not yet taken off… …”
Gary – I think it can be inferred that the police wouldn’t storm a plane that had already taken off.
There has to be more to the story. Right now it’s clickbait. Jon Biederman is right – something very off with this story. Time will tell.
@Common Sense — I’ve called you out on this before, but your use of ‘Jew’ above is a bit… ‘off.’
Like, I hope you do actually care, but it seems more like you’re just fanning the flames here, which, because it’s VFTW, and nearly anything goes, you can do whatever Gary will allow, but, just keep in mind, if you’re genuinely referring to and in support of the Jewish people, there are better ways to express that.
That said, you’re always welcome to attack me personally and call me whatever silly names you’d like. I still enjoy that. Very much. Feed me.
That’s going to be an expensive lawsuit.
(Like, note how Gary referred to them as ‘Jewish Kids,’ and not ‘Jew Kids’ in the title. I think you know better. I’ve met a lot of antisemites that use ‘Jew’ in the way you do. Just sayin’…)
I am absolutely appalled that a flight crew would brand Israel a “terrorist state” and forcibly remove around 50 young Jewish children (and violently arrest their 21‑year‑old camp director) simply for singing in Hebrew. This is blatant religious and ethnic discrimination, pure intolerance in its most disgraceful form, and must be condemned wholeheartedly by all decent people.
It’s disturbing to witness some right-wingers (including #45/47) misuse the serious charge of antisemitism to merely go after political opponents and perceived enemies in their ‘culture war’ against ‘the left’ and so-called ‘wokeness’ in the USA and abroad.
I question whether they actually care about the Jewish people in Isreal or the United States, because it seems like they’re just using them as a weapon to gain and maintain their own power. After all, the guys in khakis and with the tiki torches in Charlottesville seem to support #45/47 and think He’s their guy. How does all that add up?
Similar to how anyone who dares question the CCP is automatically deemed ‘xenophobic.’ Like, I have no problem with Chinese people; I am just not supportive of authoritarian dictatorships. I like this whole ‘self-determination’ thing. And being able to speak-out if I’m not a fan of something. Liberty, or whatever.
If someone’s got a better idea, please, do share.
Gary, please post updates if you find out any more, or whether Vueling just gets away with it.
It’s telling that the assumption of the crew is that all Jews must be in favor of, be part of, and deserve the blame and punishment for the actions of the Israeli government. THAT is anti-semitism.
1990: I am trying to figure out what part of Jew-hate is inaccurate. I dislike the term anti-Semitism as it tends to water down the description of what it actually is.
Regarding the rest of the post, I honestly don’t have any idea of what you mean.
This is plain Jew hatred, and against innocent kids who have nothing to do with any wars elsewhere in the middle east. This airline deserves to be sued into oblivion.
@Common Sense — I appreciate the clarification. It remains a disturbing incident. Hope we learn more soon.
@Tom — That’s right. And if similar reasoning (or lack thereof) was used against us, Americans wouldn’t be able to travel overseas much either. Like, if we were individually blamed for each and every regrettable civilian casualty in Iraq, that’d be absurd. There is a cost of security and peace; it’s not always clean, but sometimes it is necessary.
@1990: I wasn’t even commenting on this story. I don’t know enough to be sure, but it definitely doesn’t look good. I don’t seek to jump to already formed conclusions. I can afford to wait for the truth to come out. I don’t act like the BBC and others, pumping out daily messages from Hamas about massacres that are disproven immediately and they do the same thing day after day without shame.
They don’t even bother anymore. Anyone with two brain cells could see the stories make no sense. Israel doesn’t need to gather people together in order to kill them. If they wanted to kill civilians they could have wiped out every person in Gaza on October 8th without losing single soldier. Instead they are going from booby-trapped house to booby-trapped house and have lost over 800 fine, young men so far. And they are rewarded with the idiots trying to arrest them for “genocide”. Have you ever seen a country being responsible to feed an enemy population?
I can go on and on about the insanity of what passes for normal in today’s world.
Can’t play the video — if there is a recording of a crewmember referring to Israel as a terrorist state, well, that would be valuable data.
Please keep us posted, Gary.
Off topic a bit, but it makes me recall an American Jewish colleague (professor) who was awarded a Fullbright to teach in an Arab (U.S. ally) country. It lasted a few weeks before she called it quits and came home. There was harassment and implied threats, but the tipping point was the mandatory campus rally that included a everyone singing a song about “marching to Jerusalem and killing all the Jews.”
Yeah, time to leave.
It makes me reconsider booking a flight on BA.
The reason apparently given by the crew isn’t savory, and I also wonder why would a group would think it’s appropriate or polite to break out in song on a plane they didn’t charter exclusively.
If Israel keeps conflating all jews with Israel, this is going to keep happening. Not all Jews support Zionism or the Israeli government but the propaganda is that they’re one and the same.
@Hal: Were done with you educating Jews on what Judaism is or isn’t.
Keep your garbage to yourself.
@Thing1: What a sad example of the hate and indoctrination that goes on in the Arab world and that they are trying to import to the West.
By Hal’s logic, if Syrian government allows its militia to keep killing Druze we should expect that Syrians will be harassed when they fly. Ditto for Burmese because the government of Myanmar is killing the Rohinga. And don’t forget the Chinese, where the government is committing genocide against the Uyghers and Tibetans.
Of course in this case they were not even Israelis, but French nationals.
The Reason Israel exists is because European Christians tried to exterminate them in WWII. But age old antisemitism is a culture in Europe .The importation of millions of Muslims by Europeans is a suicidal act. Unlike the Jewish religion it seeks to dominate and conquer . While the newly imported Muslims help amplify antisemitism now they will set their sights on the rest of Europeans in time. It does not appear there are enough rational Europeans to stop it.
Their is a time and a place for singing its not on a plane during boarding for one nor when the flight is operating this is not france got talent.
@1990 – “Similar to how anyone who dares question the CCP is automatically deemed ‘xenophobic.’ Like, I have no problem with Chinese people; I am just not supportive of authoritarian dictatorships. I like this whole ‘self-determination’ thing. And being able to speak-out if I’m not a fan of something. Liberty, or whatever.”
Probably one of the smartest observations you’ve made on this forum to date, at least that I’ve seen. And this is precisely where Trump failed miserably during his first term. He should have been saying this at every pandemic press conference, but he completely failed to point out this distinction even once that I can recall.
Where is President Macron’s protest against such treatment of French citizens? The silence is deafening.
How stupid is anyone to take news reports from Hamas at face value? You really think Israel is mowing down civilians at aid centers? And you unquestioningly take this from the same people that butchered women and infants? The fact that leftist media in the US and Europe is reporting this and previous Hamas lies as fact sadly is obviously working to brainwash an entire generation of retards. You own this one, leftists. The funny thing is, you really don’t want to win this. You really think fundamentalist islam is your ally? You’re dumb.
Hal:
Your comment is hateful trash.
Even if they were Israelis, treating them like this is bigoted and antisemitic.
SHAME ON HAL for justifying antisemitism.
Running Jock:
On what basis is this Karma?
Do you support bigotry and antisemitism?
Your comment is hateful trash.
@Common Sense
It would seem that they are not trying to import the hate and indoctrination but rather that they have already succeeded.
For the record, my praise of 1990 (which, at the time of this writing, is still awaiting moderation) specifically with respect to the China distinction he made was in complete isolation — and most certainly not at all in relation to that distinction as it he feels it relates to Israel. I submit that any such equivalence is completely inapt, and I am in full agreement with Mantis and Common Sense on this subject.
For the ‘GeNoCiDe’ idiots:
wow. A new level of sh_ty antisemism. Genocide/ethnic cleansing? The population of gaza grown 6× in 60 years.
Every few years some idio&!ts like you accuse us of ‘GeNoCiDe’ while their population grown ×6 times. Man! We SUCK at GeNoCidE……
Also, Funny so tell me, if we kill ‘innocent civillians’, why arent we using UNGUIDED rockets like gaza use to shot at us? Why do we use a 50M$ jet-armed with a 40K$ GUIDED missile in order to shot a 2$ terrorist? Ha? …….Go spit your antisemic bullsh*t somehwere else. ‘Genocide’ is the blood liebel of yours. Like the 1500s blood libel of ‘jews kill christians to drink their blood in religious rituals’ that you believed in. BTW, have you ever seen any country providing its enemies with aid DURING WAR!?!?
Its amazing how history repeats itself and the antisemic people will always justify their hate towards jews based on lies + lying with eyes wide open about the Jews. Weather its drinking christian blood and weather its believing other peopl’s lies about the Jews as if these lies were water in the desert. This way you feel you hate the Jews “for a reason” just to feed your inherited antisemic views.
this is very similar to pre- holocoust thing. blaming the Jews for things they did not do. spain is like what it was in the inquisition era. they are like na*iz in the making.
thats sad, thats scary, and they will pay for it.
A crash course on history of the PALESTINIAN STATE:
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been lots of things, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
(Borrowed from a friend)
A little more history for those wanting to ‘restore Palestine’.
In 132 AD the Emperor Hadrian resolved to stamp the Jews and their religion out of existence. He sold all Jewish prisoners into slavery after the revolt of Bar Kikhba, forbade the teaching of the Torah, renamed the province Syria Palaestina, and changed Jerusalem’s name to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed Israel to wipe out the national identity of Israel and the Jews.
So if you are looking to ‘restore Palestine to the Palestinians’, you need to give it back to the Jews.
I read a few articles about the incident.
1. The crew would be within their right to demand the singing stops. The language or the lyrics don’t matter–as a passenger, the last thing I need is singing onboard, even in Hebrew (and I’m Jewish). Unfortunately, they didn’t stop there.
2. What’s unclear is the role of the 21-year old camp director. If she encouraged kids to sing on the plane, well, she should’ve known better.
3. Why the police had to arrest her like shown in the video is another question. If she resisted and escalated the situation instead of following the crew’s orders, however unfair she felt they were, again, she should’ve known better.
4. We don’t know how many of the crew uttered about Israel being a “terrorist state.” Was it one of them? Were they all chanting like a slogan? If it was one bad actor, he must be fired. If more, I hope Vueling will be made to pay.
5. Finally, those of you who could think of nothing better than using this post to spew anti-Semitic garbage, KARMA will come for you one way or another.
Lets boycott Vueling and British Airways (in case they keep silent). Shame on them. Am Israel Chai!
Isreal is it some inoccent country.
They could start by removing the settlements from the west Bank. But as long as they occupy the West Bmk they are not a innocent country.
@Eddie – what on earth does your view of Israel have to do with whether Vueling was justified in kicking children off a plane?
I just crossed Vueling from my carrier list.
Low cost carrier it was. Low intellectual strength carrier it is.
@Eddie: Besides what Gary said, just because the anti Semitic UN says it’s a crime doesn’t make it one.
Use your brains.
What is the West Bank in the first place? What’s the real name for it? Why is it a crime for Jews to live there and not Arabs? Because the Jews were ethnically cleansed from the “West Bank” in 1948 by 7 genocidal Arab armies who wanted to push them into the sea, doesn’t make it ok to do it again after the Jews won back their land in a defensive war in 1967.
Doug, you chew assholes for breakfast?