American Airlines Just Axed Its Popular Money-Saving Seat Hack—Now You’ll Pay More For Basic Economy

Generally speaking American Airlines has the most consumer-friendly policies for basic economy tickets. You can bring a full-sized carry-on bag on board. You can make changes for a $99 fee if you’re an AAdvantage member. You can pay for seat assignments, or have one assigned to you free. And all status benefits for frequent flyers apply. You can even upgrade on basic economy fares.

You give up some change flexibility, and earn fewer miles and status credits, but these most-restrictive tickets can still be a good deal, especially for someone like me that’s already earned my status for next year. When I flew to Dallas a week and a half ago to speak at the Southern Methodist University Texas Economic Forum, I picked up a $58 basic economy fare and was upgraded.

The rules for these fares have been in constant flux. American first introduced basic economy with carry-on bags restricted like United. During the pandemic they not only became upgradable but also earned miles at the same rate as other fares. So they’re constantly tweaking, becoming more and less generous. It’s hard to know exactly where they end up.

In fact, American has just tightened up on one feature that passengers were using to get value while traveling with the airline.

  • After earning 15,000 Loyalty Points, AAdvantage members receive Group 5 boarding for the membership year, plus a choice of: 1,000 Loyalty Points; Priority privileges and Group 4 boarding for a trip; or 5 Preferred Seat coupons.

  • These Preferred Seat coupons get waived fees on green seats on this seat map:

  • There are other ways to get these preferred seat coupons. They’ve been prizes in sweepstakes, for instance. Using these on basic economy tickets has been much-discussed in message forums and social media.

  • But American is eliminating the ability to use these on basic economy fares.

American laid out this restriction in a recent internal memo:

Members with status can still book preferred and extra legroom seats for free on basic economy fares. But seat coupons will no longer work for other members to save money on seats when buying the cheapest fares.

About Gary Leff

Gary Leff is one of the foremost experts in the field of miles, points, and frequent business travel - a topic he has covered since 2002. Co-founder of frequent flyer community InsideFlyer.com, emcee of the Freddie Awards, and named one of the "World's Top Travel Experts" by Conde' Nast Traveler (2010-Present) Gary has been a guest on most major news media, profiled in several top print publications, and published broadly on the topic of consumer loyalty. More About Gary »

More articles by Gary Leff »

Comments

  1. “Members with status can still book preferred and extra legroom seats for free on basic economy fares” this was really helpful to me when I flew with a large group; I booked all of us in Basic Economy, and then used my PP status to put us in MCE from the get-go. The ability to book MCE seats from booking is the thing I value most about my AA status.

  2. So no real change. Only impacts those without status who have a seat coupon. Has to be a very small %. As I read it (and confirmed w AA) as lifetime Platinum I still can book MCE on BE and board in group 3

  3. It amazing how many passengers without status, purchase Basic Economy tickets don’t care where they sit. They just wait for check-in to have a seat assigned. The product serve well those are very budget conscious. The problem comes when the passenger has a change of plan!

  4. gary, when was the last time you were NOT upgraded, on any airline? (airlines only, no hotels or anything else)

  5. Basic economy is great if you have high status and flying on an American Eagle flight. Also I am a basic bytch so it suits me fine.

  6. In August I flew Basic Economy and already then I was NOT able to use my priority seat coupons.
    I will probably never be able to use them for anything.

  7. And here the whole time I was not aware that I could bounce up to better seats from basic economy with my status all this time!

  8. Cool. I want to make flying more exclusive so I can enjoy myself without children that should never be on a flight

  9. I’m trying to imagine this decision making discussion. “You know those folks who have just started giving us repeat business? Let’s piss them off before they can give us enough business to hit gold status.”

  10. Recently flew AA to Copenhagen. I am only 5’5 and was jammed into a seat with absolutely no room. It was horrible and claustrophobic. My friend ended up with cramps in her legs. I don’t know how men squeeze in with only 10 inches between seat and back of seat in front. It might be ok for short flight but not 9 to 20 hour flight. Aa lost our business

  11. You almost got me there, Gary! I’m glad it doesn’t affect elite status owner! As a Japan airline Global Club member and AA EP, having access to Flagship Lounge, Main Cabin Extra while having a shot to upgrade to First Class (Premium Economy seating really) with BE fare is why I ditched United and Delta.

  12. I have 68000 miles. I how do I get any coupons or offers? My husband and I are flying to see our daughter in Germany tomorrow. We just found out we have to pay $175 each way for our two Pcs of luggage plus $$ for our seats. This is our first time going since covid and at the additional cost of it I’m not sure we can go again. What’s the secret of getting the items you spoke about?

  13. I have pretty much given up flying unless it’s an absolute emergency. Part of the reason passengers act up so much on flights is because they are crammed together like sardines just so the airline can make even more money for upper management and CEO bonuses. It’s sad. If they want to charge more then give us more space/legroom.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *