In response to the government shutdown, the Department of Homeland Security is suspending Global Entry and TSA PreCheck. The premise is that with staff pay deferred until the end of the shutdown, fewer people will come to work, and so screeners are needed for general processing. Literally the opposite is true, and by TSA’s own statements this makes airport security less safe.
DHS Secretary Kristi Noem has taken a populist tact with this,
TSA and CBP are prioritizing the general traveling population at our airports and ports of entry and suspending courtesy and special privilege escorts.
And she makes it explicitly political,
This is the third time that Democrat politicians have shut down this department during the 119th Congress.
Of course, this move hasn’t been necessary in past shutdowns. And it literally has the opposite effect: it requires more screeners to process the same number of passengers, not fewer.
TSA’s past experience is that you need more passengers going through PreCheck when you have fewer screeners.
TSA PreCheck lines move more passengers through faster. They’re more staffing-efficient, since vetted passengers get lighter-touch security so each employee screens more passengers per hour. That’s not me, here’s a GAO report explaining not only that it’s more staffing-efficient, but means better security.
According to TSA, identifying more passengers as eligible for expedited screening will permit TSA to reduce screening resources for low-risk travelers, thereby enabling TSA to concentrate screening resources on higher-risk passenger populations.
Pushing all passengers through standard security means applying security resources equally to vetted and non-vetted travelers, which means worse security.
- Former TSA Administrator John Pistole: PreCheck doubles hourly throughput.
- Former TSA Administrator Peter Neffenger: PreCheck and Global Entry mean focusing resources on real threats by “expend[ing] fewer resources screening and inspecting low-risk travelers.”
This shift means more screening staff time will be spent on each passenger, making screening checkpoints less efficient and less effective. It’s doing the opposite of what’s claimed, because this is shutdown politics not a necessary step in the face of limited staffing.
Global Entry is probably even the more extreme example of this, because most Global Entry processing is done by machine (kiosks) instead of by individual CBP employees. The DHS suggestion that forcing Global Entry passengers to be processes by employees instead of machines somehow reduces the need for employees is… bizarre.
Kristi Noem’s statement on the decision to suspend PreCheck and Global Entry says “Shutdowns have serious real world consequences, not just for the men and women of DHS and their families who go without a paycheck, but it endangers our national security.” But it’s this decision that is creating the danger.
Noem’s job has been in jeopardy after U.S. citizen deaths tied to ICE enforcement efforts in Minneapolis. This puts her at the forefront of Trump administration efforts in the shutdown. Her political instinct is to be in front of the cameras. But it also risks making her very unpopular. She is literally the face of long screening lines at airports.
During the government shutdown in November, government-ordered flight cuts imposed mass pain on travelers, creating pressure to end the shutdown.
While TSA receives revenue from a dedicated ticket tax, it is not a dedicated payroll account and requires an appropriation for use. So passengers keep paying the TSA tax, but screeners still have their pay suspended during the shutdown, and passengers are forced into longer lines to dramatize the shutdown and accelerate the political crises.
This ratchets up pressure to end the shutdown. However, Republicans currently control the House, Senate and Presidency so it’s hard to imagine that they won’t be blamed – even if control of both congressional chambers is relatively narrow. And they’re already headed into a very challenging election later this year.
If this stupidity means fewer Republicans get elected at the midterms, then it is worth standing in line.
“However, Republicans currently control the House, Senate and Presidency so it’s hard to imagine that they won’t be blamed.”
And that’s the bottom line. I think this dumb idea is going to bite Noem, et al. in the butt, frankly.
Totally defies normal logic … and now diving into realm of random logic!
Hopefully CLEAR still functions to substitute for TSA/Pre, but lacking Global Entry will make returns to USA absolute torture!
Someone must explain reality to Kristi Noem ASAP …
… before everything blows up, big time, and the traveling public rebels with massive protests!
Btw, Gary. you saw the Hyatt overhaul was a ‘joke’, right? It is part of a study done by college students to see how fast misinformation spreads.
“However, Republicans currently control the House, Senate and Presidency so it’s hard to imagine that they won’t be blamed – even if control of both congressional chambers is relatively narrow.” —
Unfortunately, certain issues require more than merely a simple majority in either Congressional chamber, in order to pass! Also confounding is that Republicans, unlike Democrats, always have turncoat RINOs that will vote against the best interests of Republicans and side with Democrats, so simply having a (small) majority in Congress most often isn’t enough to “get things done” for Republicans!
Good. Get rid of PreCheck and Global Entry outright and focus on fixing “standard” security screening instead.
You do not know if there are other considerations and layers of security and emergency response staff.
Anyway, this is now part of Democrat regular tactics to shut down government. This time to defund law enforcement.
@Rob R Barobt – DHS says they’re doing it because of the shutdown, they say the reason they’re doing it. Your argument is that the Trump Administration is lying.
You have to be a complete moron to blame the Republicans – Screwmer and the DemocRATs are solely responsible for this shutdown, just as they were for the 6 week shutdown late last year. Real Americans will not forget this and wil vote Republican in the mid terms.
There is a certain twisted logic here. Close down conveniences that are used by better off people and the hope is that they will put pressure on the Democrats to come to the table and make concessions. The same thing happens when there is a shutdown and the most prominent national parks are the first ones closed. So it is raising the stakes and playing chicken. The fact that it makes things worse for everybody involved is beside the point.
Eliminate congressional escorts through airports if you want to save resources.
Pre Check was open at RDU when I went though at 6:45 AM.
At Logan this AM and about to use CLEAR and hope to avoid Noem’s sheet show at Terminal E.
Incompetence is the new normal.
Douchebag move from Secretary Kardashian. The only qualification these people have is the ability to be vengeful and spiteful. Zero skills or common sense.
@kimmiea
Someone needs Civics tutoring. We can get you in the same school that will teach AOC foreign policy and geography to Hank Johnson. Economics? Full class there with AOC, Mamdani, Johnson & Pritzker, Spanberger, Johnston and others.